I wrote the following after seeing multiple posts on blogs, Tumblr, and legitimate news sites basically slut shaming Rory Gilmore in “Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life” for decisions she makes regarding men. Some of it isn’t actually slut shaming, some of it is simply die-hard fans who, like me, have probably watched the original series many times and have a romanticized idea of what Rory is like and how she should behave; they are disappointed, these fans, that thirty year old Rory isn’t making the same decisions as twenty year old Rory.
I think there are many factors to consider before judging Rory too harshly.
First of all: it’s been ten years. No one dates exactly the same way they did ten years ago. She’s in her thirties now, she’s less inhibited, less shy, more open to experiences. As humans grow, we change, see things differently. Rory is going to have a different mindset at 32 than she did when she was nineteen.
Secondly: We don’t know what her dating experience has been since leaving college. Previous relationships have a great affect on how a person treats future romantic partners. It’s possible she’s had one too many terrible boyfriends since Logan. Also: Rory’s a bit of a nomad, it’s difficult to maintain exclusive relationships when you’re constantly moving. Believe me, I know.
Thirdly: As a person ages, she becomes less idealistic. Young people often have a rigid sense of morality, Rory certainly did. This is why kids will often (foolishly) write off friends for not meeting a certain moral standard (see Veronica Mars). But as we age and mature, we realize there’s a lot of gray in the world, and we are not the ultimate voice of right and wrong in the universe. So we sleep with that guy we met at that party, and we drink the tequila, and drive to NYC to watch an SNL rehearsal and get a hot dog just to turn around and drive home again the same day.
Fourth: People also become less optimistic. Which seems strange considering people become less cynical (unless you’re Louis C.K., or a dyed-in-the-wool New Yorker) as they get older, but when it comes to relationships and dating, single, straight, American women seem to become more pessimistic about relationships. Consider this Garfunkel and Oates song.
Fifth: We don’t know what sort of relationship Logan has with this French woman. Maybe it’s an open relationship? Maybe he has the same deal with her as he has with Rory? The French are way less puritanical about sex than Americans.
We, especially those of us who grew up alongside Rory, want her to be a sort of moral beacon since she’s just like us only better, but really she’s not. Rory is just as flaky as we are, she’s just as confused, just as meandering, just as flawed. She is searching for her place in the world the same way we are.
And, as with all things, the viewer brings his or her own experience to the story. All my girlfriends who are married, engaged, or in long term relationships had the same reaction: “Rory has had ample time to find someone new, loving, and stable, why is she back with old boyfriends and making these decisions?” While all my fellow single girlfriends in their early thirties looked at Rory and said: “Yeah, nope, that’s exactly right!”
This post is edited slightly from the original post on Tumblr.